You would be jealous if you couldn't find gold.... He can say what he wants but its more than just the detector, its person running it that makes them successful, he thinks a top of the line detector in his mind is going to make the hunter, sorry its the other way around. If my detectors are so below his flavor of the month detector why do we find gold that he can't seem to?
Because he is not a beach hunter, he like a newbie who grabs a detector and just goes and meanders around a beach, will you find gold ? sure but not in the numbers a person who has skills will.
Everything I know, I learned on my own not watching a wannabe on a video...
I research the beaches I hunt, I pay attention to tides and wind direction, I can read the beach when I show up.
I'll keep hunting with my Excal and Nox, I don't need anything else. When you go over gold with the excal you know whan you are over gold.. I don't utter "it might be gold"
I just watched his video again to listen more intently, and I noticed a glaring fact he omitted. Throughout the video, he kept stressing "mild to moderate N. Carolina beaches". OK, so he's doing his testing on mild to moderate beaches in N.C. But it was the part of the video where he says Joe Beechnut and Clive are "caught", as if they've been busted for lying, which I think he seemed to imply, that they weren't being truthful about the Fisher AQ PI, so he "caught" them. He must have seen both of them discussing the AQ on a Treasure Talk episode.
BUT he wasn't comparing apples to apples. What he failed to realize, never mentioned or took into consideration was the fact that Joe and Clive aren't hunting "mild to moderate N. Carolina" beaches. I can't speak for Clive, but I know where Joe hunts as I live not too far from him. He hunts in the brackish, dark & murky saltwater of the Chesapeake Bay and previously hunted N. Atlantic beaches in OC. I've hunted in OC a few times but mostly I prefer going up the road a little bit to the beaches in DE, and I can tell ya that they're highly mineralized. I did an AI request for mineralization in the Chesapeake Bay and AI said:
The mineralization of saltwater in the Chesapeake Bay is highly variable, defined by a salinity gradient that ranges from nearly fresh in the north to ocean-strength in the south. Joe is in the Middle Bay which is considered "Brackish", which has a Mineral Concentration (Salinity) range from 0.5 to 25 ppt, as it's a mixture of fresh and ocean water. The mineralization can vary based on time of year, rainfall, river runoffs, etc. So, the mineralization in the Bay can change on a consistent basis. Further south of Joe the water averages 25 to 30 ppt at the mouth where it meets the Atlantic Ocean. For context, full-strength ocean water is approximately 32–36 ppt.
Then, if we look at N. Atlantic beaches in DE, just north of OC (where I like to hunt) and OC (where Joe liked to hunt), we start to encounter Black Sand. Ever hear about Black Sand?
Black Sand is HIGHLY mineralized, and wreaks total havoc on SMF/VLF detectors, causing them to lose quite a bit of depth. Most operators say that to try to use their SMF/VLF detectors over Black Sand, they need to turn their sensitivity way down, just to keep the detector from screaming, so those detectors lose quite a bit of depth when trying to hunt over Highly Mineralized Black Sand, not the "mild to moderate" sand like in N. Carolina.
While Black Sand causes SMF/VLF detectors to lose quite a bit of depth, it's no problem for a PI, as mineralization has no effect on a PI due to having different technology than an SMF/VLF. I did a quick AI search on Black Sand:
Black Sand
Black sand is considered
highly mineralized, often serving as a primary source for "strategic" raw materials like titanium and iron. It falls
at the top of the mineralization scale, specifically within a category known as heavy mineral sands.
Mineralization Level of Black Sand
Unlike standard "tan" sand, which is dominated by low-density silica (quartz) and feldspar, black sand is a concentrated accumulation of
heavy minerals with high specific gravity (typically greater than 2.85 or 2.9).
Relation to Other Sands
In terms of total mineral variety and density, black sand is among the
most mineralized sands in the world.
My point here is that Joe's results with his Fisher AQ is based on the waters/beaches that HE HUNTS, not based on mild to moderate beaches in N. Carolina. We're talking 2 totally different areas of the country, with beaches that have totally different mineralization conditions. So, at a "mild" beach, or in dry sand which generally has low mineralization, a SMF detector might be close or as deep as a PI. But once you get down to the salt water covered wet sand and then submerge the coil in salt water, things change drastically.
In our waters up here, with much higher levels of mineralization, a PI's gonna go deeper than an SMF, especially on highly mineralized beaches and/or over Black Sand. On low mineralized dry sand, they might be neck and neck or close to each other. But once you get down to the low wet and/or into the ocean, where saltwater enters the equation, the PI has the advantage. So, for him to say Joe is "lying" and that he's now been "caught", based on some testing he did on a N. Carolina beach with totally different conditions than the waters where Joe uses his AQ is totally incorrect.
Joe's results were based on the waters where he hunts, not the waters in N. Carolina. He should bring those detectors up here to our beaches and see how they do, compare apples to apples.
BTW, speaking of Black Sand, several months ago, wife and I took a trip down to DE for a couple days and I got to hunt for 2 days while we were there. On the first day, got to one of the beaches I planned to hunt, and
this is what I encountered, BLACK SAND, EVERYWHERE, sand that falls at the top of the mineralization scale. This was a beach where a PI would shine, I don't even think my BBS Sovereign would do well, but my Dual Field PI certainly would. Here's a few pics to show what I was seeing on that beach, just to show the conditions we encounter in our area, compared to the "mild to moderate" beaches in N. Carolina.