Nickel (Buffalo) hunt - Part II

ToySoldier

Forum Supporter
Joined
Nov 22, 2018
Messages
2,947
Location
Kentucky
Part I from earlier this week is here: https://metaldetectingforum.com/showthread.php?t=272061

I returned to the same permission with the same plan and settings to find a buffalo nickel. I still didn't find one, but what happened instead is just nuts.

My first hole had a jumpy nickel signal. I found an old pull tab, pinpointed another target deeper in the hole, and then popped out a nickel with a silver rim. I've yet to find a shiny newer nickel at this site, so I was pretty sure it was a war nickel. I had already dug three other war nickel years ('42,'43,'45) from this site. I usually wait until I get home to clean coins, but I just had to verify and then check to see if it was a '44. As is sometimes the case with war nickels, this one came out of the ground with a thick black tarnish. I was really rubbing to get a date! The first photo below is after I rubbed it enough to get a date. Sure enough, a '44.

Then, I remembered I gave the 1943 war nickel I found on the property to the owner in appreciation for the permission. At the time I wasn't thinking I'd find all four.

So, I move 10 feet to my second nickel signal and out pops another black nickel with a silver rim. Rub, rub, rub. A 1943 to replace the one I gave away. Maybe karma is a thing. A war nickel in each of my first two holes, and the dates I needed.


The first two photos are the two war nickels I dug today. The third photo shows the results of today's hunt. That makes 38 nickels from the site so far, with 8 from the 1940s. I still think there's a decent chance of a buffalo.

The fourth shows the complete set of war nickels from the site.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20190404_181707183.jpg
    IMG_20190404_181707183.jpg
    98.8 KB · Views: 227
  • IMG_20190404_183933229.jpg
    IMG_20190404_183933229.jpg
    84.2 KB · Views: 174
  • IMG_20190404_215623815.jpg
    IMG_20190404_215623815.jpg
    62.5 KB · Views: 162
  • DSC_0364.jpg
    DSC_0364.jpg
    49.2 KB · Views: 183
Last edited:
That, is full blown awesome! Congrats on those. I'd love to find a buff or war nickel...heck I'd like to find anything silver. ��

Congrats on fulfilling your Nickel Success with the War Nickels. Hope you quest for that Buffalo is in the future. Trapper

Thanks all. I won't have a chance to get out again for a few days, but there's going to be Part III. There's a buffalo out there somewhere and I'm going to get it!

There's no lack of nickel range signals on this site. On the first hunt I was digging solid 13s on the Equinox as well as 12/13s and 13/14s that mostly stayed on 13. On the second hunt I was picky and stuck with solid 13s and some that jumped down to 12. I was lucky on those first two holes, but I ended up digging fewer targets and as a result found fewer coins. The plan for the next nickel hunt is to dig anything that mostly repeats 13 and try to go as fast as I can. More trash, but more chances for a buffalo, including one that might be under a pull tab.
 
Buffalos are my favorite coin to find, but congrats to you on those war nickels. Iā€™ve had pretty good success cleaning them by microwaving a cup of hydrogen peroxide, soaking them, and finally rubbing them with a baking soda/water paste.
 
That's some great detecting you've done....finding all those nickels!! You get a big 'way to go" from me for sorting them outta all that trash!! Hope you can fulfill your Buffalo Dream there soon. Good Luck
 
Back
Top Bottom