Detector prospector forum closed. What????

Unfortunately they still have that shill on Finds Treasure misleading people.😒
John is very much a Garrett guy. I like his posts. He puts in a lot of field time. He also finds a wide range of treasure that nobody here would turn down using his choice of machine. I call that being an Ambassador, not being a shill. I happen to like Garrett. Their products have always been high quality. Their customer service is the best in any class. Always has been.
 
ask Steve to hand it off.. I'm sure he would give it if it were going into the right hands.
My understanding those talks are long gone. Personally, I like how Steve operated, however not sure he is the sharing type when it comes to his internet work. Unfortunately.
 
John is very much a Garrett guy. I like his posts. He puts in a lot of field time. He also finds a wide range of treasure that nobody here would turn down using his choice of machine. I call that being an Ambassador, not being a shill. I happen to like Garrett. Their products have always been high quality. Their customer service is the best in any class. Always has been.
But the vortex was a dismal failure after all of the hype.
 
But the vortex was a dismal failure after all of the hype.
I guess that depends on your expectations. There were quite a few of us encouraging Garrett to offer a cutting edge flagship version of the Vortex. So far they have chosen to just offer their traditional middle of the road performance/value level for VLF. That is all most people need or want. It is what sells. They know their market. They also knew the market for a new PI, and the Garrett Axiom is close to the top as far as field performance/value.
 
John is very much a Garrett guy. I like his posts. He puts in a lot of field time. He also finds a wide range of treasure that nobody here would turn down using his choice of machine. I call that being an Ambassador, not being a shill. I happen to like Garrett. Their products have always been high quality. Their customer service is the best in any class. Always has been.
There's nothing wrong being a garett guy and I like the gold sluicing post. His hard work, accomplishments and friendship with C G can make him an ambassador but he's more than that he's a SHILL. I base this on many of his post that were misleading at the least - like saying the Blue Turd had great separation when at the time it would go over a nail then miss a quarter a foot away on the same swing. 🙄 Or as a moderator on the other forum where I believe he deleted member's post and implied their accounts could be deleted when they pointed out the B T's defects.
BTW I don't hate G. I actually like the Apex but like most of their detectors they're way over priced. Last year I was at a dealer and he still had 3 that he couldn't sell since their release. Why, because the price. You can get a waterproof double score for less money. A Triple Score with 2 coils and wireless headphones for the around the price of their 16 year old atp. A great performing Legend with 2 coils and wireless headphones for around the price of a B T. Like others they do have good customer service and should especially at these prices.
If the B T was G's best effort then they need to give up. IMO anyone recommending a G over N, ML or XP must be or should be on G's payroll (and maybe a little ashamed too). I'm sorry if this makes anyone angry. Flame away if you wish, I'm not going to argue, this is only my opinion.
 
Everyone's got one.
We are all fortunate to have so many really good choices as far as equipment in the hobby today.
 
Muddy Mo, are you a shill for Nokta? Odd that you only mentioned Nokta detectors. Or maybe you're Calabash? That guy is the ultimate shill who also hates Garrett.

Say what you will, but here's MY opinion. The AT Pro is still a great machine. Just a reminder of what I've found with it:

1) 14K gold Omega Constellation wristwatch.
2) 10K gold lion pendant.
3) 1878 CC seated dime (200k mintage).
4) Drawer full of 1700's and 1800's flat buttons.
5) 1700's shoe buckles, buttons and more.
6) 1785 bar cent (extremley rare, worth 10k in better shape).

zero omega watch 4.jpeg
10k gold medallion.jpeg
zip seated dime obverse.jpeg
relics 4.JPG
relics 5.JPG
1785 bar cent.JPG
 
No, I'm not a low life shill, I have morrows and a concionce. I haven't had a notka for around 3 years and have no desire to get another. I'm not married to any brand. I have 3 ML, 3 Fisher, 2 Tesoros, 2 whites, 1 Tec and a Quest.
I'm not Calabash, we both see the facts, that doesn't make me him.
You miss what I say in my post, I don't hate G and never said the atp won't work. I said you can get better machines for less money and others intentionally 'misleading' people is reprehensible. I don't believe C D hates them either other than their prices vs their performance.
Congrats on your finds they're very nice! but finds don't equal a detector's value. You can catch a trophy fish on a cane pole. That doesn't mean they should sell for more than graphite rods with quality reels..
Other detectors..
(Amazon pricing for convenience)

Ace 400 - 20 yrs old tech? Single freq, not waterproof, no rechargeables $360
VS
ML Vanquish 360- smf, waterproof, rechargeable $250

Apex- smf, not waterproof, wireless but only with optional $100 zlink $385
VS
Vanquish 460- smf, waterproof, BT wireless, $350

ATP- single freq, waterproof, proprietary wireless (not included) $460
VS
Vanquish 560- smf, waterproof BT wireless (not included) $400

Blue Turd 9- still having problems? and not close to other top tiers, detector alone $600
VS
Vanquish Elite- with 2 coils and wireless headphones $525

Nit pick but I seriously doubt anyone here would choose the Garrett's in these comparisons unless extreme brand loyalty or new to detecting.
 
It does seem odd that the AT Pro is still priced around $460.00. Guess they still sell enough so they don't feel the need to drop the price any lower. They were around $550 when I bought mine used about 10 years ago. I got one that was a year old and still under warranty for $400, I believe.
 
From somebody who knows nothing about AI that sounds very interesting.

Can you give an example of it's work? Perhaps ask it for settings for a specific detecting scenario and then give it's answer?

Just curious what I am missing out on by being a Luddite! 😂
i was using chatgpt AI and it remembers things I have asked it. I talked about living in north atlanta and was hunting an 1894 homesite that has been lived in continuously

So if you have no history with chatgpt just give it some and ask the questions you want to know.

I live in north Atlanta and I am metal detecting an 1894 five acre homesite. The house is still on the land and has been lived in continuously with the exception of the last two months when it was bought by developers. The soil is about 6 inches of good darker dirt above red clay. I am using a minelab manticore and I want to know the best setting to hunt this lot. There is a lot of rusted iron all around the house and in the back yard.

here is what chatgpt reported back:
For your 1894 North Atlanta homesite, I would set up your Minelab Manticore specifically for old coins, silver, and brass relics in iron-contaminated ground. With five acres of continuously occupied property, you have an excellent opportunity to find items from the late 1800s through the 1900s.
Your soil description is particularly useful: six inches of darker topsoil over Georgia red clay. The most important challenge will probably be the rusty iron, not the soil itself. Iron can mask good targets, create misleading signals, and make desirable coins difficult to separate from nearby junk.
My recommendation is to use a relatively fast, iron-aware setup near the house, then switch to a slightly more depth-oriented setup in the less contaminated parts of the yard.

1. My recommended Manticore settings​

These are the starting settings I would use on your property. They are tailored for old coins and relics mixed with nails, rusty hardware, and other iron.
[IMG alt="Minelab Manticore Metal Detector
– DetectorUSA"]https://images.openai.com/static-rs...r8Eh8Ga66xghJ68W8wTvgcko?purpose=inline[/IMG]



Old Homesite — Iron Separation​

Starting profile for the house and iron-heavy yard
Recommended starting setup

Search modeAll-Terrain → General
FrequencyMulti-IQ+
Recovery Speed6
Sensitivity22, then adjust for stability
Ferrous LimitsPreset, Upper 8–9; Lower 4
Stabiliser2–3 to start, if available
Noise CancelAuto
Ground balanceGround balance over a clean patch; tracking off initially
DiscriminationKeep it minimal; don't reject broad low-conductive ranges
Ferrous VolumeLow but audible
Why these settings? Minelab explains that higher Recovery Speed helps separate nearby targets but sacrifices some depth and Target ID accuracy. Its newer Stabiliser feature is specifically intended to make responses more manageable in iron-contaminated sites.
favicons

Minelab+2

One important adjustment: If you are getting a tremendous amount of iron noise, try Recovery Speed 7. If you move to a relatively clean section of the property, try 4–5 to gain more depth on isolated targets.

2. How I would hunt the five acres​




Zone A — Within about 20 feet of the house
  • Use Recovery Speed 6–7.
  • Sweep slowly, with overlapping passes.
  • Investigate short, repeatable high-tone signals even when iron is nearby.
  • Re-sweep from 90 degrees to the original direction before deciding a target is junk.
This is where nails, roofing debris, fasteners, and household hardware can mask coins.




Zone B — Backyard and likely activity areas
Look for old paths, gates, former clothesline areas, shade trees, garden edges, and places where people may have sat or worked.
Start at Recovery Speed 5–6. Search in overlapping lanes, then cross-hatch the most promising sections. These locations may have fewer nails than the immediate house perimeter while still producing dropped coins and personal items.




Zone C — Outer yard and less disturbed ground
Reduce Recovery Speed to 4–5, provided the ground is stable. Keep Multi-IQ+ enabled and test for deeper signals.
Search systematically. An area that looks empty may contain older coins or relics that are too deep to stand out in a quick pass.

3. How to handle all that rusty iron​

This is where I would spend the most time fine-tuning your Manticore.
  • Don't eliminate too much iron with Ferrous Limits. Raising the upper limit can reduce false iron responses, but it can also impair separation between iron and good targets. Start conservatively.
    favicons

    Detector Warehouse+1

  • Keep the Stabiliser low initially. Try 2, then 3 or 4 if rusty iron is producing convincing false high tones. Excessive stabilization can suppress useful details.
  • Listen for changes in the signal. A coin beside a nail may sound broken from one direction and become much more repeatable when approached from another.
  • Don't rely on Target ID alone. A desirable target partially masked by iron can give inconsistent numbers and a distorted trace on the Manticore's 2D ID Map.
  • Remove the iron when practical. Digging and removing larger rusty objects can make the next pass substantially more productive.
Minelab's official guidance describes Ferrous Limits as a trade-off: rejecting more iron falsing can reduce target-separation performance.
favicons

Detector Warehouse+1

4. What your six inches of topsoil over red clay means​

Your soil profile gives you a useful starting point, but the red clay deserves a little testing.
  • Ground balance: Balance over a clean patch away from nails and large iron. If you hear ground-related noise or see unstable IDs, ground-balance again.
  • Depth: Don't assume a coin is beyond reach just because it is in the clay. A coin at the topsoil/clay boundary may still be detectable, depending on its size, orientation, mineralization, and nearby iron.
  • Sensitivity: Start at 22. If the detector chatters without a target, lower it a couple of points. Stable sensitivity is generally more useful than maximum sensitivity in a noisy yard.
  • Coil control: Keep the coil level and close to the ground. Avoid lifting it at the ends of each swing.

5. A simple test that can improve your results​

Before searching the entire property, find a reasonably clean patch and bury a few test targets at known depths, such as a modern penny, a silver coin, and a small brass item. Test them individually, then place a rusty nail nearby and repeat.
Try Recovery Speeds 4, 6, and 7. Compare the audio, 2D trace, and repeatability from different directions. This will show you which setting works best with your detector, soil, and coil.
For the full operating details, use the official Minelab Manticore instruction manual.

One question that would help me fine-tune your settings​

When you say there is a lot of rusty iron, which situation best describes the yard?
What kind of iron are you encountering?

Thousands of small nails and screws

A mixture of nails, bottle caps, and rusty scraps

Large iron objects, pipes, stove parts, or sheet metal

All of the above, with iron signals almost everywhere

Which coil are you using?

Standard 11-inch M11 coil

9-inch M9 coil

6-inch M8 coil

Another coil or unsure
Fine-tune my settings
With those two details, I can recommend a more precise Recovery Speed, Ferrous Limits, Stabiliser, and discrimination strategy for your particular site.
 
i was using chatgpt AI and it remembers things I have asked it. I talked about living in north atlanta and was hunting an 1894 homesite that has been lived in continuously

So if you have no history with chatgpt just give it some and ask the questions you want to know.

I live in north Atlanta and I am metal detecting an 1894 five acre homesite. The house is still on the land and has been lived in continuously with the exception of the last two months when it was bought by developers. The soil is about 6 inches of good darker dirt above red clay. I am using a minelab manticore and I want to know the best setting to hunt this lot. There is a lot of rusted iron all around the house and in the back yard.

here is what chatgpt reported back:
For your 1894 North Atlanta homesite, I would set up your Minelab Manticore specifically for old coins, silver, and brass relics in iron-contaminated ground. With five acres of continuously occupied property, you have an excellent opportunity to find items from the late 1800s through the 1900s.
Your soil description is particularly useful: six inches of darker topsoil over Georgia red clay. The most important challenge will probably be the rusty iron, not the soil itself. Iron can mask good targets, create misleading signals, and make desirable coins difficult to separate from nearby junk.
My recommendation is to use a relatively fast, iron-aware setup near the house, then switch to a slightly more depth-oriented setup in the less contaminated parts of the yard.

1. My recommended Manticore settings​

These are the starting settings I would use on your property. They are tailored for old coins and relics mixed with nails, rusty hardware, and other iron.
[IMG alt="Minelab Manticore Metal Detector
– DetectorUSA"]https://images.openai.com/static-rs...r8Eh8Ga66xghJ68W8wTvgcko?purpose=inline[/IMG]



Old Homesite — Iron Separation​

Starting profile for the house and iron-heavy yard
Recommended starting setup

Search modeAll-Terrain → General
FrequencyMulti-IQ+
Recovery Speed6
Sensitivity22, then adjust for stability
Ferrous LimitsPreset, Upper 8–9; Lower 4
Stabiliser2–3 to start, if available
Noise CancelAuto
Ground balanceGround balance over a clean patch; tracking off initially
DiscriminationKeep it minimal; don't reject broad low-conductive ranges
Ferrous VolumeLow but audible
Why these settings? Minelab explains that higher Recovery Speed helps separate nearby targets but sacrifices some depth and Target ID accuracy. Its newer Stabiliser feature is specifically intended to make responses more manageable in iron-contaminated sites.
favicons

Minelab+2

One important adjustment: If you are getting a tremendous amount of iron noise, try Recovery Speed 7. If you move to a relatively clean section of the property, try 4–5 to gain more depth on isolated targets.

2. How I would hunt the five acres​




Zone A — Within about 20 feet of the house
  • Use Recovery Speed 6–7.
  • Sweep slowly, with overlapping passes.
  • Investigate short, repeatable high-tone signals even when iron is nearby.
  • Re-sweep from 90 degrees to the original direction before deciding a target is junk.
This is where nails, roofing debris, fasteners, and household hardware can mask coins.




Zone B — Backyard and likely activity areas
Look for old paths, gates, former clothesline areas, shade trees, garden edges, and places where people may have sat or worked.
Start at Recovery Speed 5–6. Search in overlapping lanes, then cross-hatch the most promising sections. These locations may have fewer nails than the immediate house perimeter while still producing dropped coins and personal items.




Zone C — Outer yard and less disturbed ground
Reduce Recovery Speed to 4–5, provided the ground is stable. Keep Multi-IQ+ enabled and test for deeper signals.
Search systematically. An area that looks empty may contain older coins or relics that are too deep to stand out in a quick pass.

3. How to handle all that rusty iron​

This is where I would spend the most time fine-tuning your Manticore.
  • Don't eliminate too much iron with Ferrous Limits. Raising the upper limit can reduce false iron responses, but it can also impair separation between iron and good targets. Start conservatively.
    favicons

    Detector Warehouse+1

  • Keep the Stabiliser low initially. Try 2, then 3 or 4 if rusty iron is producing convincing false high tones. Excessive stabilization can suppress useful details.
  • Listen for changes in the signal. A coin beside a nail may sound broken from one direction and become much more repeatable when approached from another.
  • Don't rely on Target ID alone. A desirable target partially masked by iron can give inconsistent numbers and a distorted trace on the Manticore's 2D ID Map.
  • Remove the iron when practical. Digging and removing larger rusty objects can make the next pass substantially more productive.
Minelab's official guidance describes Ferrous Limits as a trade-off: rejecting more iron falsing can reduce target-separation performance.
favicons

Detector Warehouse+1

4. What your six inches of topsoil over red clay means​

Your soil profile gives you a useful starting point, but the red clay deserves a little testing.
  • Ground balance: Balance over a clean patch away from nails and large iron. If you hear ground-related noise or see unstable IDs, ground-balance again.
  • Depth: Don't assume a coin is beyond reach just because it is in the clay. A coin at the topsoil/clay boundary may still be detectable, depending on its size, orientation, mineralization, and nearby iron.
  • Sensitivity: Start at 22. If the detector chatters without a target, lower it a couple of points. Stable sensitivity is generally more useful than maximum sensitivity in a noisy yard.
  • Coil control: Keep the coil level and close to the ground. Avoid lifting it at the ends of each swing.

5. A simple test that can improve your results​

Before searching the entire property, find a reasonably clean patch and bury a few test targets at known depths, such as a modern penny, a silver coin, and a small brass item. Test them individually, then place a rusty nail nearby and repeat.
Try Recovery Speeds 4, 6, and 7. Compare the audio, 2D trace, and repeatability from different directions. This will show you which setting works best with your detector, soil, and coil.
For the full operating details, use the official Minelab Manticore instruction manual.

One question that would help me fine-tune your settings​

When you say there is a lot of rusty iron, which situation best describes the yard?
What kind of iron are you encountering?

Thousands of small nails and screws

A mixture of nails, bottle caps, and rusty scraps

Large iron objects, pipes, stove parts, or sheet metal

All of the above, with iron signals almost everywhere

Which coil are you using?

Standard 11-inch M11 coil

9-inch M9 coil

6-inch M8 coil

Another coil or unsure
Fine-tune my settings
With those two details, I can recommend a more precise Recovery Speed, Ferrous Limits, Stabiliser, and discrimination strategy for your particular site.
Thanks for that, it was very interesting! It almost sounded like it knew what it was talking about! 🤣

Joking aside, I think it's definitely a technology I need to play with....
 
I try to follow the idea that the best machine to use is the one you have and the better machine
is the one you want to buy next... Garret, Nokta, MineLab... None of it matters much if all you do
is go out and turn it on without learning how to use it beyond anything other than turning the
volume up or down...
 
Back
Top Bottom