Detector prospector forum closed. What????

maxxkatt

Forum Supporter
Joined
Sep 20, 2015
Messages
4,686
Location
North Atlanta, GA
I just learned of this when logging on DP after a long absence this morning. Steve sited the decrease in activity due to people using Robbed Material from his forum to answer questions posed to AI companies. This has always been a big issue of AI companies literally stealing and not paying for information they scraped and repackaged and gained ad revenue. As much as I like, AI this stinks. AI can never replace the fellowship of a good forum like Detector Prospector and this forum. And yes AI does scrape our MD forums. I have seen some references to member's posts when I ask chatgpt about some Manticore settings.

There is some code you can as a person or company having a web site place in your web site code called "no index" and it will tell search bots like google to skip your site. Does no index statement even work anymore? Do AI bots ignore this statement? I would guess this is the truth. I rather guess these guys on their way becoming billionaires tend to ignore a lot of things.
 
AI companies are doing the ask for forgiveness instead of permission strategy. As long as they're worth billions, they'll get away with it.
 
Facebook Groups and AI are slowly killing off dedicated forums. Its a shame. People have gotten lazy and are willing to sacrifice quality for convenience. FB Groups are an unorganized mess to navigate but people are willing to deal with it rather than taking a little extra time to register at a website with a well organized forum. Same with AI. Why spend time browsing forums and interacting with real people when you can just use AI to quickly snag an answer based off of information it took from those very forums. No index and robots.txt don't do squat when rogue crawlers and AI scraping can just bypass it.
 
I just learned of this when logging on DP after a long absence this morning. Steve sited the decrease in activity due to people using Robbed Material from his forum to answer questions posed to AI companies. This has always been a big issue of AI companies literally stealing and not paying for information they scraped and repackaged and gained ad revenue. As much as I like, AI this stinks. AI can never replace the fellowship of a good forum like Detector Prospector and this forum. And yes AI does scrape our MD forums. I have seen some references to member's posts when I ask chatgpt about some Manticore settings.

There is some code you can as a person or company having a web site place in your web site code called "no index" and it will tell search bots like google to skip your site. Does no index statement even work anymore? Do AI bots ignore this statement? I would guess this is the truth. I rather guess these guys on their way becoming billionaires tend to ignore a lot of things.
Steve closed DP because he was tired of being a baby sitter. All the bickering, BS, finger pointing and being a baby sitter he just wanted to move on and do more of what he wanted. Enjoying life.

If I remember correct he was thinking this for several years before and had a couple friends who helped to extend the open time, but finally he decided it was time.

{EA24528F-1128-442A-A897-64CED9486DD1}.png
 
Last edited:
Actually the no index will just have you not be returned in search results. AI will still scrape the sites, but you won't get as much organic traffic if you aren't indexed on google....

This may not be true anymore, or may not have been true and I may just have an imperfect understanding of how it works. Tech-years go faster than dog-years now.
 
Actually the no index will just have you not be returned in search results. AI will still scrape the sites, but you won't get as much organic traffic if you aren't indexed on google....

This may not be true anymore, or may not have been true and I may just have an imperfect understanding of how it works. Tech-years go faster than dog-years now.
My background is computer programming so I decided to use AI to understand AI. Here is a basic overview. Air is all about word context. For instance the word bank can be a money bank or a river bank. It looks at the context of words around it like fishing or deposit, balance, river etc to determine a numerical ranking for which is the like match. That is just one easy example to to understand. From there it uses mostly mathmatical formula or process or functions to deliver the desired results of asked questions against stored values. This is one reason AI chips are so massive in their power consumption. Normal internet servers pre AI used extremely simple processes of just data movement.

you search for data, you find data, you manipulate data, you display data, you store data. These are very low powered uses of chip compared to AI chips that are 1,000 x more powerful and that 1,000x may be 12,000 x who knows? Thus AI data centers are massive consumers of electricity to power the data center and water to cool these very hot running chips.

Few people actually understand how AI really works. Certainly the top level programmers do, but it is doubtful that their managers do and management above the first line management level probably don't have a clue about the nuts and bolts. But they do certainly know how to make money from AI as do the topside billionaires. My programming experience comes from being a senior systems analyst for Alcoa and Paramount Pictures. Our immediate supervisors rarely had a clue to how we did what we did. Oh they pretended to know to their supervisors, but they did not. I promise you that this was true then and probably true even now.
 
I used to do other types of stuff on other types of forums and youtube. You used to have to watermark your photos a long time ago. Ai can wipe a watermark out now. Also a lot of my vids got copied and posted abroad. Bypassed my YouTube content on the subject. Lots of lazy people on earth trying to make a buck. Other type of forum I was on I deleted what content I could and hung it up. Used to moderate one of my friends fb page. That job suxs!
 
He seemed like it. There is another admin on his site Chase Goldman who was called Hugh. Boy he could go really deep into the weeds with discussing the physics behind metal detecting settings. Plus he was a nice guy that would answer all of my sometimes stupid questions. Does anyone know where he is now? At one time he was on Tereasurenet with a different user name which I forgot. That's what happens when you effecitvely take two years off of your metal detecting hobby. Use it or loose it.
 
He seemed like it. There is another admin on his site Chase Goldman who was called Hugh. Boy he could go really deep into the weeds with discussing the physics behind metal detecting settings. Plus he was a nice guy that would answer all of my sometimes stupid questions. Does anyone know where he is now? At one time he was on Tereasurenet with a different user name which I forgot. That's what happens when you effecitvely take two years off of your metal detecting hobby. Use it or loose it.
Chase lives in Maryland or Delaware. I know he has hunted some of the same places I have so he can't be to far away. Their are several that were on Steves forum and Treasure Depot that have disappeared. :?: One Ive not seen in awhile is Casper.. He was every where except steves
{3C614BB2-DA5B-4592-A984-7E8A711D4498}.png
 
My background is computer programming so I decided to use AI to understand AI. Here is a basic overview. Air is all about word context. For instance the word bank can be a money bank or a river bank. It looks at the context of words around it like fishing or deposit, balance, river etc to determine a numerical ranking for which is the like match. That is just one easy example to to understand. From there it uses mostly mathmatical formula or process or functions to deliver the desired results of asked questions against stored values. This is one reason AI chips are so massive in their power consumption. Normal internet servers pre AI used extremely simple processes of just data movement.

you search for data, you find data, you manipulate data, you display data, you store data. These are very low powered uses of chip compared to AI chips that are 1,000 x more powerful and that 1,000x may be 12,000 x who knows? Thus AI data centers are massive consumers of electricity to power the data center and water to cool these very hot running chips.

Few people actually understand how AI really works. Certainly the top level programmers do, but it is doubtful that their managers do and management above the first line management level probably don't have a clue about the nuts and bolts. But they do certainly know how to make money from AI as do the topside billionaires. My programming experience comes from being a senior systems analyst for Alcoa and Paramount Pictures. Our immediate supervisors rarely had a clue to how we did what we did. Oh they pretended to know to their supervisors, but they did not. I promise you that this was true then and probably true even now.
I am a proponent of AI... It's an extremely useful tool and I have a decent grasp on how it works. I was more specifically referring to SEO and indexing of websites on google... Since more and more people are using AI agents to do internet searches (not the best strategy to find the most current info btw unless your agent actually is doing web searches and not relying on training data) SEO years seem shorter than dog years now...
 
I also use the chatgpt version of AI for the past 6 months. I find it invaluable for planning business for profit ideas. Learning my new Manticore it seems to have a lot of very accurate information at it's fingertips. Compare this to trying to learn the Equinox 800 many years ago in the early months of its release. Not fun. Remember the often very heated debates between the AT Pro users and the new Equinox 800 users? Not a pretty site and drove some admins on this and other MD forums crazy.

If you ask chatgpt many questions about your metal detecting it will remember a lot of things like the types of your more recent hunts and give you the setting for instance in my case for an 1894 old home that has been occupied as a working farm house since 1894. It seems that most of the settings and tips are accurate. I cross check them with a well known member on here who is very knowledgeable with the multifreq machines like the XP Deus 2 and Manticore. So far AI has been right on the mark.
 
I use AI daily and find it to be invaluable. Google searches to me now are archaic, crude, and inefficiant.
 
I use AI daily and find it to be invaluable. Google searches to me now are archaic, crude, and inefficiant.
When searching on google and most others the first 3 pages are selling something and or the same one sided answers from biased sites repeated over and over. AI usually seems to get their answers from the first page of results.The Internet is starting to be worthless.
 
When searching on google and most others the first 3 pages are selling something and or the same one sided answers from biased sites repeated over and over. AI usually seems to get their answers from the first page of results.The Internet is starting to be worthless.
Unless AI does an active current web-search then it's relying off of the data it was trained with... Which usually has a cut-off period. You can usually ask the AI you are using what the cut-off date for it's training data was. GIGO. But then information has always been like that. Just more efficient now with AI.
 
If you ask chatgpt many questions about your metal detecting it will remember a lot of things like the types of your more recent hunts and give you the setting for instance in my case for an 1894 old home that has been occupied as a working farm house since 1894. It seems that most of the settings and tips are accurate. I cross check them with a well known member on here who is very knowledgeable with the multifreq machines like the XP Deus 2 and Manticore. So far AI has been right on the mark.
From somebody who knows nothing about AI that sounds very interesting.

Can you give an example of it's work? Perhaps ask it for settings for a specific detecting scenario and then give it's answer?

Just curious what I am missing out on by being a Luddite! 😂
 
I had to lookup "Luddite"- that may be my brother's new nickname. He still has a flip phone and doesn't even text.
 
A lot of good websites are struggling to justify producing quality written content, especially in a small niche like metal detecting.

As more people turn to AI for answers, many publishers are seeing fewer website visits, which means less advertising revenue and fewer affiliate sales. Meanwhile, hosting costs money, researching and writing useful articles takes time, and getting that content seen takes even more work. For many independent publishers, the return simply doesn’t cover the effort.

It’s especially frustrating when AI summarizes information from those websites without readers ever visiting the original source. Ad blockers add another challenge. I understand why people use them, but they also reduce the revenue that helps pay for the content people enjoy.

Behind a good metal detecting article is someone testing equipment, researching history, documenting finds, or sharing knowledge gained through years of experience. Passion can keep that work going for a while, but it doesn’t pay the bills.

Some YouTubers earn substantial money, although plenty struggle too. For websites focused on written content, it's harder than ever to make a sustainable income.

The problem isn’t that written websites can never make money. It’s that smaller niche publishers (which metal detecting falls under, even though we think it is an awesome niche) often earn very little from the traffic they receive. One 2026 blogging survey reported average AdSense earnings of just $3.26 per 1,000 pageviews—about $326 for 100,000 pageviews, before hosting, research, writing, and promotion costs.

My concern is that we’ll keep losing dedicated, knowledgeable publishers—and the hobby will lose valuable resources along with them.
 
Back
Top Bottom